For the past decade, I have been thinking about a single problem: how to build a global social safety net. And I kept hitting the same wall — literally.
The border.
National social safety nets are bounded by national borders. A country can afford to give its citizens a basic income, but it cannot easily give it to the citizens of another country. The fiscal and political constraints seem insurmountable.
But let's do a thought experiment. What if the money spent on building physical walls was instead used to build social safety nets across borders? What if the United States took the billions of dollars it spends on border enforcement and walls, and used them to fund a Universal Basic Income (UBI) in Mexico?
I. The Logic of Migration
People do not migrate because they want to leave their homes. They migrate because they cannot survive in their homes.
If the choice is between starving in a place you love, or risking your life to cross a border for a better life, most people will take the risk. It is not a choice between two good options; it is a choice between two forms of desperation.
Now, imagine a different scenario. What if, in Mexico, every citizen had a guaranteed basic income — enough to cover food, shelter, and basic dignity? What would happen to the incentive to migrate?
Most people would stay. They would build their lives, raise their families, and contribute to their communities. They would not risk their lives crossing a desert if they could live with dignity at home.
The primary driver of migration is not the desire for a better life. It is the absence of a survivable life at home.
II. The Absurdity of Walls
The United States has spent billions of dollars on border walls and enforcement. Yet migration continues. Why? Because walls address the symptom, not the cause.
The cause of migration is the lack of a social safety net in the country of origin. When people cannot survive at home, they will find a way to leave, regardless of how high the wall is or how many guards are posted.
Walls are also expensive to build and maintain. They require constant surveillance, maintenance, and personnel. And they generate enormous human suffering — deaths in deserts, children separated from parents, communities torn apart.
Compare this to the cost of a Universal Basic Income in a neighboring country. For a fraction of the cost of border enforcement, you could provide a basic income to millions of people. You could eliminate the primary driver of migration.
III. The Border is a Fiscal Boundary
The deeper issue here is the relationship between borders and fiscal policy. A border is not just a line on a map; it is a fiscal boundary. Inside the border, the state has a fiscal obligation to its citizens. Outside the border, that obligation ends.
But the problems we face — migration, climate change, inequality — do not respect borders. They are global problems that require global solutions.
This is why a global social safety net is necessary. Not just as a moral imperative, but as a practical solution to practical problems. If we want to stop migration, we must address the conditions that drive it. And that means providing a basic income to people wherever they are.
IV. The Political Barrier
Of course, there are political barriers to this idea. Politicians who propose funding a UBI in another country will be accused of "giving away money to foreigners" or "putting domestic citizens last."
But this is a short-sighted view. The money spent on border enforcement is far greater than the money that would be required to fund a UBI in a neighboring country. And the outcomes — reduced migration, reduced human suffering, increased stability — would be far better.
The problem is not fiscal. It is political. It requires a shift in perspective: from thinking about borders as walls, to thinking about borders as fiscal boundaries that need to be managed globally.
V. The Deeper Structural Issue
But even this solution — funding a UBI in a neighboring country — is only a partial fix. Because it does not address the root cause of the problem: the global fiscal system that allows transnational capital to extract wealth from the periphery while refusing to fund social safety nets.
If we want to build a global social safety net, we must address the structural inequalities in the global economy. We must capture the value that capital extracts from developing countries and redirect it towards public goods. We must treat borders not as barriers to be defended, but as fiscal boundaries to be managed cooperatively.
This is why the GL Framework and the concept of land value public capture are essential. They provide the fiscal tools to fund a global social safety net. They allow us to think beyond the borders of the nation-state, and to imagine a world where everyone has a basic income, not just the citizens of wealthy countries.
VI. Conclusion
The choice between walls and bread is not just a policy choice; it is a philosophical choice. It is a choice between a world divided by borders and defended by walls, and a world connected by shared safety nets and funded by shared wealth.
The cost of walls is high — not just in money, but in human lives, in human suffering, in the erosion of our common humanity. The cost of bread is also high, but it is a cost that we can afford, and it is a cost that would produce a better world.
This is not just an idea. It is a structural necessity. If we do not build a global social safety net, we will continue to build walls. And the walls will not save us.